Crisis on Infinite Earths #7

Originally published in COMICS BUYER'S GUIDE #954 (28 Feb 1992), Krause Publication

>>>

George Perez writes:

After 17 years, imagine my surprise to actually be writing a second letter to your publication within one month's time. I am addressing my comments to Mark Engblom's letter (and, indirectly, to John Byrne's message to you by voice mail) regarding my comments about homage covers in general and the cover of Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 in particular.

First, Mark, thanks for bringing this particular subject out into the light. I originally had a statement in my letter pertaining to this exact case but decided to delete it because it made me sound self-serving and it took away from the intent of the letter. If I recall correctly (and I may be wrong, since I don't have a copy of my original letter in front of me), I said that the only conscious instances of my copying another artist's cover design were the Action Comics and The New Titans covers to which I referred. The incredible similarity between the Crisis #7 cover and the Uncanny X-Men ("Death of Phoenix") cover was simply one of those crazy coincidences that pop up in this industry from time to time. (And provide for great subjects of speculation in the recurring deja vu feature.)

For those who tuned in late: The Uncanny X-Men cover to which Engblom referred showed Cyclops cradling a dead Phoenix in a pose eerily similar to the one of Superman cradling the equally dead Supergirl on my later Crisis cover. When I was first approached about it by a fan years ago, I admit that I was bowled over. I hadn't read an issue of Uncanny X-Men in some time and could honestly not recall ever having seen John's cover, and I definitely didn't use it as my design guide. However, the layout was so startlingly similar that even I began to doubt whether or not I was inadvertently inspired by it.

For the record, my original inspiration for the cover was an early Jack Kirby cover showing Odin cradling Thor. I wanted to get the same impact, but designed it totally on my own without actually referring to the Kirby piece to suit the needs of the comic book on which I was working. It's like having a super-hero fly and immediately imagining Curt Swan's Superman as an inspiration without deliberately aping his style or composition. If John (or anyone else for that matter) thinks I actually took my Crisis cover idea from him, I just want to say here and now that it wasn't so. If it were, I certainly would have acknowledged it. However, having been a fan of John's work for many years, it wouldn't surprise me if some of his design sense just rubbed off on me, much as it has with so many artists whom I have admired.

Thanks for giving me the chance to clear things up.

Uncanny X-Men #136 (August 1980)
art by John Byrne and Terry Austin

Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 (Oct 1985)
DC Comics

Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 (Digital) (22 Sep 2010)
DC Comics

Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 Poster (1998)
DC Comics

Note: Background characters are colored

CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS STATUE (20 Oct 1999)
DC Direct

sculptor: Tim Bruckner

MIGHTY MOUSE #4 (Jan 1991)
Marvel Comics

art: George Perez

ADVENTURE COMICS #5 (Dec 2009)
DC Comics

art: Jerry Ordway

ACTION COMICS #973 (Variant Cover) (08 Feb 2017)
DC Comics

art: Gary Frank

DCEASED #2 (Arthur Suydam cover) (05 Jun 2019)
DC Comics

art: Arthur Suydam

SUPERGIRL #79 (26 Feb 2003)
DC Comics

art: Ed Benes/Alex Lei
colors: Tanya Horie

SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL #10 (Apr 1992)
DC Comics

art: Jon Bogdanove/Dennis Janke

FIRESTORM #21 (Jan 2006)
DC Comics

art: Jamal Igle & Keith Champagne

VALOR #18 (May 1993)
DC Comics

art: Stuart Immonen/Dick Giordano

THE MULTIVERSITY: PAX AMERICANA #1 (Incentive Cover) (19 Nov 2014)
DC Comics

art: Patrick Gleason

Dark Crisis #1 (Gotham Comics Variant) (07 June 2022)
DC Comics

art: Tyler Kirkham

APE-RIL SPECIAL #1 (19 Mar 2024)
DC Comics

art: Bernard Chang/Hayden Sherman

MAJOR BUMMER #12 (Jul 1998)
DC Comics

art: Doug Mahnke

HARLEY QUINN: UNCOVERED #1 (Dec 2022)
DC Comics

art: Ryan Sook / George Perez

BATMAN/DEADPOOL #1 (Nov 2025)
DC Comics/Marvel Comics

art: Ryan Sook

DEADPOOL & CABLE #25 (Apr 2010)
Marvel Comics

art: Rob Liefeld

SUPERMAN #41 (KINGDOM OF ZOD) (26 Aug 2026)
DC Comics

art: Jason Badower

ROGUES #3 (July 12, 2022)
DC Comics

art: Max Dunbarr & John Kalisz

TRINITY #1 (2025)
DC Comics

art: Lucas Meyer

MR JUSTICE #2 (Jan 15, 2025)
Archie Comics

art: Matt Talbot

ASSORTED CRISIS EVENTS #9 (15 July 2026)
Image Comics

art: Eric Z

ROGUE SUN #29 (Aug 2025)
Image Comics

art: Stefano Simeone

SHADOWHAWK #5 (Cover B) (Dec 2010)
Image Comics

art: Jim Valentino / Chance Wolf

WITCHBLADE #128 (Cover B) (Jul 2009)
Image Comics

art: Luke Ross

G.I. JOE #6 (Cover B) (05 Oct 2011)
IDW

art: Robert Atkins

FALLEN ANGEL #16 (Cover A) (May 2007)
IDW

art: Benjamin Hobbs

BUFFY SASON 9 #10 (13 June 2012)
Dark Horse

art: Georges Jeanty

QUCK STOPS #2 (Dec 2022)
Dark Horse

art: Phillip Hester and Ande Parks with colors by Francesco Segala

CRISIS ON INFINITE CEREBI #1 (26 Sep 2018)
Aardvark Vanaheim

art: Benjamin Hobbs

CIMMERIAN QUEEN OF BLACK COAST #2 (06 Nov 2019)
Ablaze

art: Ed Benes

ANYMAN (2022)
Spellbound Comics

art: David Baldeon / Tom Ziuko

MID-LIFE CRISIS #2 (19 Jul 2017)
Comic Book School‎

art: Andy Seabert

COMIC BOOK GUY: THE COMIC BOOK #1 (Jul 2010)
Bongo Comics

art: Matt Groening / Delaney / Pepoy

SAGA OF A DOOMED UNIVERSE #3 (Cover B) (28 Dec 2022)
CEX Publishing

art: Scott Reed

TEAM FORTRESS #6 (10 Jan 2017)
Valve

art: Heather "makani" Campbell

FLEISCHER #3 (Jan 2012)
Bluewater Comics

art: Fernando Sosa and Merbitt

FANBOYS VS ZOMBIES #1 (Suydam Cover) (Apr 2012)
Boom! Studios

art: Arthur Suydam

PATHFINDER: WORLDSCAPE #1C (Variant Cover) (19 Oct 2016)
Dynamite

art: Sean Izaakse

WASTED SPACE #1 (Second Printing) (30 May 2018)
Vault Comics

art: Darick Robertson

RICK & MORTY #44 (Supercon Variant) (30 Nov 2018)
Oni Press

art: Greg Kilpatrick

TOM STRONG #22 (Dec 2003)
America's Best Comics

art: Chris Sprouse/Karl Story

FRINGE: TALES FROM THE FRINGE #4 (Variant) (Sep 2010)
Wildstorm Publishing

art: Carlos D'Anda / JJ Kirby / Michael Lopez

NINJA HIGH SCHOOL VERSION TWO #11 (May 2000)
Antarctic Press

art: Ben Dunn

SUPERGIRL S02E02: The Last Children of Krypton (17 Oct 2016)
The CW

Supergirl: Kevin Smith Director T-Shirt (2016)
art by Jeff Quigley

JUSTICE LEAGUE: CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS - Part Three (Bluray) (Dec 2024)
Warner Bros.

CHIKARA: TAG WORLD GRAND PRIX - NIGHT 2 (DVD) (Feb 2006)
Chikara

TOYFARE: THE TOY MAGAZINE #75 (Cover B) (Sep 2003)
Wizard Press

COMICS BUYER'S GUIDE #1300 (16 Oct 1998)
Krause Publication

art: Fred Hembeck

DOOM PATROL #3 (09 Nov 2016)
DC Comics

"It's a Doomed World After All" by Gerard Way with art by Nick Derington

Team-Ups: CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS (Nov 2005)
VS System

art: Phil Noto

FRINGE: Crisis on Infinite Earths #7 (2010)

art: Carlos D'Anda / JJ Kirby / Michael Lopez

Fringe Alternate Crisis #7 (2010)

art: Juvaun Kirby

DEATH OF PREZ (2005)
Art by George Perez

Death of Supergirl (1999)
Art by George Perez

CRISIS #7 - Christopher Reeve and Helen Slater (2019)
Art by Alex Ross

LEGION OF SUPERHEROES (2015)
Art by John Watson/Russell Payne

Devilman / Go Nagai (2019)
Art by Juan Soto

DEATH OF ZATANNA (2011)
Art by Ian Richardson, colors by Alfa Jang

SPIDER-MAN & MARY JANE WATSON (Apr 2023)
Art by Bob Layton

DEATH OF MARK DOMINIC (Dec 2019)
Art by Alex Garcia

Crisis on Gervasio's Earth (2018)
Art by Ganzo McFly

Wonder Woman / Supergirl (2020)
Art by Lee Xopher

GRAVITYMAN (2020)
Art by Paul Soeiro

CRISIS IN INFINITE RINGS (2021)
Art by Hal Haney

George Perez Tribute (2022)
Art by AfizethArt

Crisis in Infinite Quarantine (2020)
Art by monstersngeeks

Crisis on Infinite Earths Animated (2021)
Art by Matías Lértora

Transformers (Unpublished) (2022)
Art by Don Allan Figueroa

Crisis on Infinite Wabbits (2025)
Art by Dave Lung‬

Page updated

Google Sites

Report abuse